11 of the Best Intriguing Books like The Mysterious Benedict Society

If you’re a fan of thrilling mysteries, cunning young protagonists, and mind-bending adventures similar to “The Mysterious Benedict Society,” you’re in for a treat. In this literary journey, we’ll unveil 11 captivating books like The Mysterious Benedict Society that will tickle your curiosity, challenge your intellect, and transport you to worlds teeming with secrets and enigmas.

Whether you’re seeking to unravel complex puzzles, decode hidden messages, or embark on a riveting quest, these handpicked titles are sure to keep you turning pages well into the night. So, get ready to discover a treasure trove of the best intriguing books that capture the essence of “The Mysterious Benedict Society” and take you on unforgettable journeys of suspense and intrigue.

Books like The Mysterious Benedict Society

Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children (2011)

by Ransom Riggs

This young adult fantasy novel follows Jacob Portman, a teenage boy who discovers a hidden world of peculiar children with extraordinary abilities after his grandfather’s mysterious death. His journey begins when he visits the remote island where his grandfather claimed to have spent his youth at an orphanage run by Miss Peregrine. Jacob stumbles upon the ruins of the orphanage and soon realizes that the children who once lived there were not ordinary; they possessed peculiar powers.

Miss Peregrine, their guardian, keeps the children safe. However, the children face a threat that seeks to consume peculiar souls.

Jacob’s own peculiar ability, which he discovers he shares with his grandfather, becomes a crucial element in this battle. The story combines vintage photographs with a captivating narrative, blurring the line between reality and fantasy.

Total Pages– 352 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 3.92

Amazon Rating– 4.3

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 11 hours and 44 minutes to finish Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children by Ransom Riggs.

A Series of Unfortunate Events (1999)

by Lemony Snicket

With a dark, grim setting, ‘A Series of Unfortunate Events’ by Lemony Snicket (a pen name for Daniel Handler) is a 13-book series that follows the tragic and mysterious lives of the Baudelaire siblings – Violet, Klaus, and Sunny – after their parents die in a fire. The children are placed under the care of a distant relative.

Throughout the series, the Baudelaires face a series of unfortunate events, encountering bizarre situations, eccentric characters, and people’s attempts to capture their fortune. Despite their intelligence and resourcefulness, the siblings are often misunderstood by the incompetent adults around them.

Violet is an inventor, Klaus is a bookworm, and Sunny is a baby with extraordinary biting abilities. As they navigate a wide array of perilous situations, they uncover clues about their parents’ past and the secret society to which they were connected.

If you liked the children and their wits in ‘The Mysterious Benedict Society,’ you must read this series, for you’ll find the same aspects that will captivate you.

Total Pages– 176 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.00

Amazon Rating– 4.6

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 5 hours and 52 minutes to finish #1 book of A Series of Unfortunate Events.

The Willoughbys (2008)

by Lois Lowry

‘The Willoughbys’ by Lois Lowry follows the eccentric Willoughby family, consisting of four children – Tim, Jane, Barnaby A, and Barnaby B – who come from a long line of ancestors who have been illustrious and wealthy. However, their parents are neglectful and selfish, prioritizing their own desires over their children’s well-being. The children decide that they would be better off as orphans and concoct a plan to send their parents on a dangerous vacation, hoping that they won’t return.

As their plan unfolds, the children encounter an abandoned baby on their doorstep, which leads to unexpected adventures. They cross paths with a kind nanny named Nanny Pete, who changes their perception of family dynamics and nurtures them with genuine care and attention.

Through humour and wit, the book parodies classic children’s literature tropes while addressing themes of family, love, and self-discovery. As the Willoughby children’s journey unfolds, they learn the true meaning of family and find themselves forming a new kind of bond with each other and the people they meet along the way, just like in ‘The Mysterious Benedict Society.’

Total Pages– 174 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 3.81

Amazon Rating– 4.6

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 5 hours and 48 minutes to finish The Willoughbys by Lois Lowry.

Tales of the Black Widowers (1974)

by Isaac Asimov

A collection of mystery short stories written by Isaac Asimov, ‘Tales of the Black Widowers’ revolves around a group of friends who gather once a month for dinner at the fictional Milano Restaurant. The club is called the Black Widowers due to the group’s habit of inviting a different guest to each dinner, a guest who is usually requested to present a puzzling or mysterious problem.

In each story, a guest recounts a baffling problem, often a mystery or an enigmatic situation, to the members of the Black Widowers. The stories typically involve logical deduction, rational analysis, and clever insights as the club members work together to solve the presented mystery. Henry, the waiter at the Milano Restaurant, is a recurring character who serves as a sounding board for the club’s discussions.

The book highlights Asimov’s talent for blending his interest in science and logic with the mystery genre.

Total Pages– 224 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 3.90

Amazon Rating– 4.4

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 7 hours and 28 minutes to finish Tales of the Black Widowers by Isaac Asimov.

Good Omens (1990)

by Neil Gaiman, Terry Pratchett

‘Good Omens’ is a comedic fantasy novel that playfully explores the impending apocalypse. The story follows an unlikely duo: Aziraphale, a somewhat fussy angel, and Crowley, a demon with a penchant for rebellion. They have both been on Earth since its creation and have grown rather fond of humanity’s quirks. However, when they learn that the Antichrist has been born and the end of the world is imminent, they team up to prevent the apocalypse they’ve inadvertently come to enjoy.

As the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse gather and chaos ensues, the angel and demon work to uncover the true identity of the Antichrist. Their efforts lead them through various hilarious and absurd situations involving witch hunters, witchfinders, prophecies gone awry, and a young boy named Adam who unknowingly holds the fate of the world in his hands.

Total Pages– 512 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.25

Amazon Rating– 4.6

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 17 hours and 4 minutes to finish Good Omens by Neil Gaiman and Terry Pratchett.

Mr. Penumbra’s 24-Hour Bookstore (2014)

by Robin Sloan

This novel follows the story of Clay Jannon, an unemployed web designer who stumbles upon a peculiar bookstore in San Francisco. The store, owned by the enigmatic Mr. Penumbra, operates 24/7 and seems to cater to an odd clientele interested in obscure books. Clay discovers that the books are written in a code that seems to hold secrets.

Curiosity drives Clay and his friends, on a mission to get to the bottom of the shop’s real purpose. What follows is a fantastical series of events involving an international secret society and almost impossibly complex codes hidden inside a series of books. It’s a collision of ancient mystery and very modern, internet-savvy characters.

In both the books the characters embark on quests to uncover hidden knowledge or secrets and are exceptionally intelligent and engage in problem-solving and critical thinking.

Total Pages– 288 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 3.73

Amazon Rating– 4.2

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 9 hours and 36 minutes to finish Mr. Penumbra’s 24-Hour Bookstore by Robin Sloan.

Skulduggery Pleasant (2007)

by Derek Landy

“Skulduggery Pleasant” by Derek Landy follows the story of Stephanie Edgley, a 12-year-old girl who discovers a hidden world of magic and danger after the death of her eccentric uncle Gordon. At the reading of Gordon’s will, Stephanie encounters the enigmatic Skulduggery Pleasant, a witty and powerful detective who is also a reanimated skeleton. Skulduggery introduces Stephanie to the magical realm and her own latent magical abilities.

As they delve into the mystical underbelly of Dublin, they uncover a plot by the evil sorcerer Nefarian Serpine to gain immense power. Stephanie and Skulduggery must work together to thwart Serpine’s plans and save the world from his malevolent grasp.

The book is a thrilling blend of magic, mystery, and humour as Stephanie navigates her new life as a part of the magical community and joins forces with Skulduggery to stop Serpine’s reign of terror. With engaging characters, witty dialogues, and a fast-paced plot, this series will definitely remind you of ‘The Mysterious Benedict Society.’

Total Pages– 392 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.18

Amazon Rating– 4.5

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 13 hours and 4 minutes to finish Skulduggery Pleasent by Derek Labdy.

The Rook (2012)

by Daniel O’Malley

This supernatural thriller that follows Myfanwy Thomas, a woman who wakes up with no memory in the middle of a London park surrounded by bodies wearing latex gloves. She discovers that she’s a high-ranking operative in a secret government organization called the Checquy, tasked with managing supernatural threats to Britain. Before her memory loss, Myfanwy had left her future self a series of letters that guide her through the intricate and often dangerous world of the Checquy.

As Myfanwy navigates her dual identity—piecing together her past and adapting to her powerful position—she uncovers a conspiracy involving a rival supernatural group, the Grafters. She must rely on her wit, newly discovered supernatural abilities, and alliances within the Checquy to unravel the mystery and protect the organization from impending danger.

Total Pages– 504 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.10

Amazon Rating– 4.4

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 16 hours and 48 minutes to finish The Rook by Daniel O’Malley.

Neverwhere (1996)

by Neil Gaiman

‘Neverwhere’ is a dark fantasy novel that follows the journey of Richard Mayhew, an ordinary young man living in London. His life takes a drastic turn when he helps a mysterious young woman and becomes intertwined with London Below, a hidden and magical world beneath the city’s streets. In this hidden realm, Richard encounters a mix of eccentric characters, both human and supernatural, as he navigates through a world of danger and intrigue.

As Richard assists the mysterious woman in her quest to uncover her family’s truth, he discovers that London Below is a place of both wonder and peril, inhabited by those who have fallen through the cracks of society. With the help of allies like the Marquis de Carabas and the enigmatic Hunter, Richard learns to adapt to this new reality and confront his own strengths and weaknesses.

The novel masterfully blends urban fantasy with a dark, imaginative narrative, as Gaiman weaves a tale of magic, mystery, and self-discovery.

Total Pages– 370 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.17

Amazon Rating– 4.5

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 12 hours and 20 minutes to finish Neverwhere by Neil Gaiman.

The Wednesdays (2012)

by Julie Bourbeau

In Max’s seemingly ordinary village, every day unfolds predictably, except for the anomaly known as Wednesday. On this peculiar day, most villagers lock themselves inside, shutting windows and locking doors to avoid the bizarre incidents that transpire. However, Max’s insatiable curiosity drives him to defy all village norms and embark on a quest to uncover the origins of Wednesday’s peculiar occurrences.

In this realm, known as “The Wednesdays,” imagination runs wild. Robin soon realizes that The Wednesdays offer a chance to escape from the challenges of his everyday life.

As Robin navigates this extraordinary world, he meets various characters. However, the story also explores the fine line between reality and fantasy, raising questions about the consequences of escaping into an imaginary realm. Robin must come to terms with his struggles and responsibilities in both the real world and The Wednesdays.

Total Pages– 256 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 3.59

Amazon Rating– 4.1

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 8 hours and 32 minutes to finish The Wednesdays by Julie Bourbeau.

Nevermoor (2017)

by Jessica Townsend

Morrigan Crow is a cursed child born on Eventide, fated to die at midnight. However, she is saved from her impending doom by a mysterious man named Jupiter North and transported to the magical city of Nevermoor. There, Morrigan discovers a world of wonder and danger, filled with remarkable creatures and enchanting places.

To remain in Nevermoor and escape her cursed fate, Morrigan must compete in a series of trials to join the Wundrous Society, a prestigious organization of talented individuals. Assisted by her new friends and her innate ability to manipulate a mysterious substance called Wunder, Morrigan faces various challenges. The trials test her courage, wit, and resourcefulness, as well as uncover her unique talents.

As Morrigan navigates the trials, she also faces a shadowy threat connected to her past, which puts her newfound home in jeopardy. With the help of her friends and Jupiter, she unravels secrets and confronts her fears to save Nevermoor from a sinister danger.

Like ‘The Mysterious Benedict Society,’ ‘Nevermoor’ is a tale of bravery, friendship, and self-discovery, set in a captivating and whimsical world where magic is real and anything is possible.

Total Pages– 465 pages

Language- English

Goodreads Rating– 4.34

Amazon Rating– 4.7

If you read at a standard rate, say 30 pages per hour, it will take you 15 hours and 30 minutes to finish Nevermoor by Jessica Townsend.

Conclusion to Books like The Mysterious Benedict Society

And that concludes the list for books like The Mysterious Benedict Society!

If you liked ‘The Mysterious Benedict Society,’ you are sure to love the books in the above list. In the exciting journey through books like The Mysterious Benedict Society, you’ll explore clever kids solving puzzles. These stories teach teamwork, quick thinking, and friendship. If you enjoyed the mysteries and adventures, keep reading! Many more books await with similar fun and brain-teasing quests. Grab a book, join the adventure, and let your imagination soar.